Menu
215 South Hamilton Street, Madison, WI
Lunch (Only Available After 11!)
Sandwiches
The Justice Burger
Double smash patty, cheddar cheese, pickled red onion, shredded lettuce, bacon tomato jam, garlic aioli, on a house-made brioche bun$14.75The Judge and Jury Burger
Double smash patty, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, on a house-made brioche bun.$13.50Trial Turkey Sandwich
Deli turkey, cucumber, tomato and arugula with scallion cream cheese on a toasted sub roll$12.25The Bench Balsamic Mushroom
Balsamic marinated mushrooms, roasted garlic basil hummus, tomato, & spinach, on Toasted Whole Wheat Sourdough.OUT OF STOCK$11.75The Commish
Roast Beef, Cheddar Cheese, Horseradish sauce, Roasted Poblano and Bell Peppers on Stalzy's French Roll. Comes with a side of mixed greens$13.50Search & Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Crispy Bacon, Romaine Lettuce & Caesar Dressing in a Flour Tortilla Wrap, served with a side of mixed greens$12.75
Vegan Hex-a-dilla
Black bean masa patty, pico de gallo, spicy hummus, wrapped & grilled in flour tortilla, comes with side salad!$13.75
Salads
Walkin The Beet Salad
Roasted Beets, Bay poached apples, pickled red onions, goat cheese, mixed greens, pepitas and maple mustard viniagrette$8.50Southwest Salad w/ Chicken
Grilled Chicken, Avocado, Smokey Corn and Black Bean relish, cherry tomatoes on crunchy romaine lettuce tossed with our house ranch dressing.$9.50
Mock Trial *Only Available Saturday 3/7/26*
Mock Trial
Bacon Cheese Burger
Cates Family Farm beef topped with American cheese and crispy bacon on our house-made bun. Served with mixed greens.OUT OF STOCK$13.75Chaperone Burger
Cates Family Farm beef, cheddar cheese, bacon, BBQ pulled pork and BBQ sauce on our house-made bun, served with a side of mixed greens.OUT OF STOCK$16.50Search & Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Crispy Bacon, Romaine Lettuce & Caesar Dressing in a Flour Tortilla Wrap, served with a side of mixed greens$12.75Pulled Pork Sandwich
Pulled Pork on a Brioche bun topped with pickled onions (or pickled jalapeno), chipotle aioli. Served with side salad (or upgrade to fries!)$14.50Classic Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup
Classic combo of cheddar cheese griddled on Madison sourdough bread and house-made tomato soup!OUT OF STOCK$11.00Fries
Hot and crispy$4.00Tomato Soup
Made from scratch, vegan tomato basil soup!OUT OF STOCK$5.00Mixed Greens
Served with our house maple-mustard vinaigrette$2.50
Mock Trial
Bacon Cheese Burger
Cates Family Farm beef topped with American cheese and crispy bacon on our house-made bun. Served with mixed greens.OUT OF STOCK$13.75Chaperone Burger
Cates Family Farm beef, cheddar cheese, bacon, BBQ pulled pork and BBQ sauce on our house-made bun, served with a side of mixed greens.OUT OF STOCK$16.50Search & Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Crispy Bacon, Romaine Lettuce & Caesar Dressing in a Flour Tortilla Wrap, served with a side of mixed greens$12.75Pulled Pork Sandwich
Pulled Pork on a Brioche bun topped with pickled onions (or pickled jalapeno), chipotle aioli. Served with side salad (or upgrade to fries!)$14.50Classic Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup
Classic combo of cheddar cheese griddled on Madison sourdough bread and house-made tomato soup!OUT OF STOCK$11.00Fries
Hot and crispy$4.00Tomato Soup
Made from scratch, vegan tomato basil soup!OUT OF STOCK$5.00Mixed Greens
Served with our house maple-mustard vinaigrette$2.50
Mock Trial
Bacon Cheese Burger
Cates Family Farm beef topped with American cheese and crispy bacon on our house-made bun. Served with mixed greens.OUT OF STOCK$13.75Chaperone Burger
Cates Family Farm beef, cheddar cheese, bacon, BBQ pulled pork and BBQ sauce on our house-made bun, served with a side of mixed greens.OUT OF STOCK$16.50Search & Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Crispy Bacon, Romaine Lettuce & Caesar Dressing in a Flour Tortilla Wrap, served with a side of mixed greens$12.75Pulled Pork Sandwich
Pulled Pork on a Brioche bun topped with pickled onions (or pickled jalapeno), chipotle aioli. Served with side salad (or upgrade to fries!)$14.50Classic Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup
Classic combo of cheddar cheese griddled on Madison sourdough bread and house-made tomato soup!OUT OF STOCK$11.00Fries
Hot and crispy$4.00Tomato Soup
Made from scratch, vegan tomato basil soup!OUT OF STOCK$5.00Mixed Greens
Served with our house maple-mustard vinaigrette$2.50
Mock Trial
Bacon Cheese Burger
Cates Family Farm beef topped with American cheese and crispy bacon on our house-made bun. Served with mixed greens.OUT OF STOCK$13.75Chaperone Burger
Cates Family Farm beef, cheddar cheese, bacon, BBQ pulled pork and BBQ sauce on our house-made bun, served with a side of mixed greens.OUT OF STOCK$16.50Search & Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Crispy Bacon, Romaine Lettuce & Caesar Dressing in a Flour Tortilla Wrap, served with a side of mixed greens$12.75Pulled Pork Sandwich
Pulled Pork on a Brioche bun topped with pickled onions (or pickled jalapeno), chipotle aioli. Served with side salad (or upgrade to fries!)$14.50Classic Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup
Classic combo of cheddar cheese griddled on Madison sourdough bread and house-made tomato soup!OUT OF STOCK$11.00Fries
Hot and crispy$4.00Tomato Soup
Made from scratch, vegan tomato basil soup!OUT OF STOCK$5.00Mixed Greens
Served with our house maple-mustard vinaigrette$2.50